FANews
FANews
RELATED CATEGORIES
Category Investments

Active vs passive: concentrated markets swing the pendulum back in favour of active

21 November 2023 Duncan Lamont, CFA, Head of Strategic Research at Schroders
Duncan Lamont

Duncan Lamont

The data which suggests passive strategies could come unstuck.

Global stock markets have become increasingly top-heavy. At the end of October, the 10 biggest stocks in the US S&P 500 index made up a record 31% of the market (Figure 1).

This is clearly a problem for investors trying to build diversified portfolios as a significant proportion of their risk is being driven by a relatively small number of companies.

Our new research also shows that, historically, investors passively tracking the US stock market would have lost out on returns in the years following high levels of index concentration.

At a time when investors are increasing allocating to passively managed strategies at the expense of active, the tables could be set to turn.

This is not just an issue for the US stock market. The US has grown to be 63% of the global market at the end of October (MSCI All Country World Index (ACWI) index) so international investors have ended up with a lot in US stocks and, with that, a lot in just 10 stocks. Those 10 make up nearly 18% of the global market, the same as Japan, the UK, China, France, and Canada combined.

Click here to read more...

Quick Polls

QUESTION

The latest salvo in the active versus passive debate suggests that passive has an edge in highly efficient markets, or where the share universe is relatively small. In this context, how do you approach SA Equity investing?

ANSWER

Active always, the experts know best
Active, but favour the smaller funds
Passive for the win
Strike a balance between the two
fanews magazine
FAnews October 2024 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

The township economy: an overlooked insurance market
FSCA regulates crypto assets: a new era for investors
Building trust: one epic client experience at a time
Two-Pot System rollout underlines the value of financial advice
The future looks bright for construction
Subscribe now