Category Legal Affairs

True brokers may be paid a secret commission (UK)

27 May 2021 Patrick Bracher, Norton Rose Fulbright
Patrick Bracher, Norton Rose Fulbright

Patrick Bracher, Norton Rose Fulbright

In negotiations between parties who were negotiating charterparty terms for the chartering of two vessels, third parties involved in the negotiations received commission unknown to the party paying the price for the charter of the two vessels.

It was held that although the third parties were intermediaries they were not agents in the full legal sense but true brokers.  They did not owe any single-minded loyalty to the party chartering the vessels.  Their duties were limited to communicating messages honestly.  If the only duty of the intermediaries was to transmit communications honestly, such duty was not breached by their underlying commercial motivation to maximise their commissions.

The agreement pursuant to which a broker receives secret commission or other payments is not unenforceable on the grounds of public policy or illegality in circumstances where the fact of the payments was known to the parties and it was open to the party who was aware of the market rates but unaware of the amount payable to the brokers to enquire as to the amount of the payments but chose not to do so.

The distinction is important.  Parties often use phrases like “on behalf of” and create an agency when it is a true broking arrangement where a principal/agent relationship need not be created.  The second principle, is applicable to intermediary commission.  For example, an insured cannot complain they did not know the intermediary was earning commission from the premium paid when this is well-known and ascertainable in relation to any insurance transaction.

[CH Offshore Limited v Internaves Consorcio Naviero SA [2020] EWHC 1710 (Comm)]

First published by: Financial Institutions Legal Snapshot

Quick Polls


Healthcare brokers have long complained about inflation-plus medical scheme contribution increases; but pandemic may have changed things. What will pandemic-induced changes in hospital utilisation do to medical scheme contribution increase patterns?


Below inflation increase for 2022, then back to inflation-plus
Long-term trend of below inflation increases
Inflation-linked hikes for 2022, then back to inflation-plus
This is a 2-year hiccup, inflation-plus increase trend remains in place
fanews magazine
FAnews June 2021 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Broker and insurer collaboration should not be a one-way street
Running on outdated systems… There's risks
Policy wordings with respect to COVID-19
Death or divorce... how best to split assets
Ethical investing… principles and moral codes
Portfolio positioning will serve investors well
Subscribe now