FANews
FANews
RELATED CATEGORIES
Category Investments

The cost of active equity management

02 February 2009 Plexus Asset Management

In the current environment of low and/or negative investment returns from equity funds, investors once again focus on the issue of costs. This tends to reignite the debate of passive versus active investment strategies.

This prompted a recent study by Plexus Asset Management into fund costs and returns. Plexus’ head of research, Johan Pyper, calculated that average Total Expense Ratio (TER) of South African equity funds that invest across the broad market is 1,68%. These include general equity funds, value and growth funds, large-cap funds (mostly index trackers with low TERs) and varied specialist funds.

Pyper then calculated the average total return (i.e. with dividends reinvested) achieved by the JSE/All Share Index over the long term. The return for the past 49 years is 16,95% per annum. After deducting an annual charge (TER) of 1,68% from the dividends, the Index’s net return was 15,01%. With the compounding effect of the fees, the results show that an active equity manager had to outperform the All Share Index by at least 1,94% per annum over this 49-year period just to match the performance of the All Share Index.

Unit trusts’ performance figures are always published net of TERs. This means a fund with a high TER that outperforms the market (and competitors) has done exceptionally well. Although a fund with a high TER may continue to outperform, keep in mind that a high TER makes a manager's task that much more difficult.

A further study of the average returns achieved by the abovementioned funds over various periods to date reveals that outperforming the All Share Index by more than 1,94% per annum is no easy task (see Table A).

According to Pyper, one should not conclude that a passive investment strategy of investing in index trackers - with their low TERs - is the only way to go. There are active managers who consistently outperform passive indices such as the All Share Index over the longer term. “But it is not always easy to identify the future outperformers when you are looking at history,” says Pyper. “One should also recognise that managers tend to outperform or underperform in different markets.”

Pyper believes it makes good sense to include both active and passive investment strategies in an investment portfolio. “Investors should also look at passive index trackers that are constructed according to the relatively new methodology whereby company fundamentals instead of the traditional market cap methodology are used,” he says. “There is more than sufficient evidence that this new methodology provides returns superior to those of the traditional market cap indices.”

 

Table A

Annual returns

1 Year

3 Years

5 Years

10 Years

Fund selection average

-18,21%

2,72%

16,41%

17,44%

FTSE/JSE All Share Index

-19,45%

4,41%

16,53%

17,95%

Quick Polls

QUESTION

The NHI is steamrollering ahead with a 2028 implementation mooted. How do you feel about the future of medical schemes and private healthcare under this solution?

ANSWER

Anxious about losing comprehensive coverage.
Confident the private sector will adapt.
Concerned about the lack of clarity.
Neutral, waiting to see how it unfolds.
fanews magazine
FAnews November 2024 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Understanding treaty reinsurance – and the factors that influence it
Insurance brokers: the PI scapegoat
Medical Schemes' average increases for 2025
AI is revolutionising insurance claims processing and fraud detection
Crypto arbitrage: exploring the opportunities and risks
Subscribe now