South Africa’s leading intermediary experience survey succumbs to pandemic concerns

07 May 2020 Gareth Stokes

The 2020 FIA Intermediary Experience Awards and its accompanying survey are the latest in a long line of industry events and initiatives to yield to the global coronavirus pandemic. The decision to cancel the 2020 event follows deep deliberation between the FIA executive and the association’s sponsors about the viability of conducting the survey, and hosting the subsequent celebrations, in the current economic environment. This will be the first time in 22 years that the association’s members are unable to celebrate the financial product suppliers that deliver the best overall experience to financial intermediaries across a wide range of advice disciplines.

“The FIA could not justify the financial commitment to run an extensive member survey and host a glamorous awards ceremony at a time when our members, our partners, and product suppliers are struggling with the economic consequences of the coronavirus and ensuing nationwide lockdown,” said Lizelle van der Merwe, CEO of the FIA. “Another consideration is that our members’ focus will be on retaining clients and rebuilding their businesses as the country emerges from lockdown”. She also questioned the sense in conducting a comprehensive survey of intermediary experience at a time when global economic upheaval had resulted in ‘business unusual’ in the insurance and investment sectors. 

Strained broker / provider relationships

It is quite probable that relationships between FIA members and product suppliers will be strained over coming months as clients, brokers, and insurers get to grips with their respective exposures post-lockdown. FAnews has already heard rumblings from short term insurance brokers about claims outcomes under the business interruption (BI) and contingent business interruption (CBI) sections of their client’s short term policies. South Africa is not alone in this regard and there are already dozens of class action lawsuits starting up in the United States (US) to challenge insurer’s categorisation of pandemic-related losses. Local stakeholders will be watching offshore developments with interest as governments enter the fray. 

On 25 April, Mel Stride, chairman of the United Kingdom’s Treasury Committee urged insurers to do their part in sharing the financial burden of the pandemic. “We are concerned that the insurance sector goes the extra mile in meeting claims wherever possible, for example where there may be grey areas within policies,” he said. Insurers in the US, meanwhile, are trying to come up with alternative solutions due to the non-performance of BI cover. “[US] Insurers are doing this after facing multiple lawsuits, fierce political pressure and criticism from customers with BI policies over not covering their recent financial hardships due to the novel coronavirus pandemic,” wrote Suzanne Barlyn, in a 29 April article on The US Insurance Information Institute estimates 40% of small businesses in that country had BI coverage; but that such policies either “exclude or do not specifically cover a global pandemic, however much it may interrupt business”. 

Government cannot intervene

When asked if the South African government might attempt to coerce local insurers to relax certain policy conditions to pay more COVID19-related claims, Seamus Casserly, CEO at Lockton SA, said he would be surprised if they did. “Imagine the constitutional position of a government instructing an insurer [or broker] on how to conduct its business, despite a legal contract being in force,” he said. But we digress. 

Many in the industry will mourn the loss of another standout event on the 2020 calendar. The FIA Intermediary Experience Awards has a credible history that spans more than two decades and is acknowledged as the most comprehensive ranking of financial product providers that are active in the intermediated distribution environment. It is a survey conducted among FIA member advisors, brokers, and employee benefit consultants that aims to give providers a holistic view of what is crucial in each service experience dimension. As such the awards serve as a reminder of the complex relationships that exist between advice givers and product suppliers as they join forces to deliver the best possible financial outcome to consumers. 

All is not lost. The FIA said that there were two interim initiatives on the cards to maintain the awards’ momentum and ensure a ‘new and improved’ FIA Intermediary Experience Awards in 2021. “We are busy with a review of the intermediary experience survey questionnaire,” said Van der Merwe. “An internal process by FIA staff, assisted by the various FIA executive committees, will simplify the survey and strip out unnecessary repetition”. 

Increased transparency in selection process

Product providers that have partnered with the FIA for 2020 will be asked for their inputs during the final stage of the review process. This initiative aims to increase transparency around the awards selection criteria and make it easier for product providers to deliver on intermediaries’ expectations going forward. It is further hoped that the initiative will engender a clearer understanding among financial product providers about which aspects of their distribution support and product design most resonate with intermediaries. 

A second initiative is proposed for the final quarter of 2020. “We have undertaken to meet with our 2020 FIA Partners to discuss an alternative research product to be conducted towards the end of this year,” concludes Van der Merwe. “This research will focus on the development of financial advice and intermediated distribution throughout the financial services industry, rather than a narrow focus on intermediary experiences”. The FIA will team up with is current Awards survey partner, Ask Afrika, to question its members and the broader market to get ideas for the development, evolution and recovery of the financial services sector post-COVID19. 

Writer’s thoughts:
 It was with sadness that I learned of the FIA’s decision to cancel the 2020 FIA Intermediary Experience Awards. I have attended many awards galas over the last 14 years, either as a financial journalist (for FAnews) or as communications manager for the FIA (from 2012-2017). The event serves as a credible measure of adviser sentiment insofar product providers. This pause is an opportune time to poll FAnews readers’ views of the event. What did you like or dislike about past iterations? And what would you like to see happen next year? Please comment below, interact with us on Twitter at @fanews_online or email me us your thoughts [email protected].

PS:  Take the time to watch our latest “In conversation with..” video.  In this video FAnews talks to the FIA and FPI about intermediaries and adviser’s role during COVID19.

Comment on this post

Email Address*
Security Check *
Quick Polls


The next year or two will continue to be a turbulent one with regards to regulatory change. Do you think…


What we need is less regulation not more
The industry has overwhelmed itself with its own excessive regulation
The industry is bracing itself to deal with the regulatory changes, and brokers and insurers need to stay well informed of the effects of these changes
fanews magazine
FAnews June 2021 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Broker and insurer collaboration should not be a one-way street
Running on outdated systems… There's risks
Policy wordings with respect to COVID-19
Death or divorce... how best to split assets
Ethical investing… principles and moral codes
Portfolio positioning will serve investors well
Subscribe now