Category Healthcare
SUB CATEGORIES General  |  HIV |  Medical Schemes | 

Defending members’ medical savings

26 February 2020 Josua Joubert, Chief Executive and Principal Officer at CompCare Medical Scheme
Josua Joubert, Chief Executive and Principal Officer at CompCare Medical Scheme

Josua Joubert, Chief Executive and Principal Officer at CompCare Medical Scheme

You can tell a lot about a medical scheme from how it treats members’ savings.

In 2017, a Constitutional Court ruling changed the way medical schemes report on members’ Personal Medical Savings Accounts (PMSAs). Instead of being recorded as liabilities in scheme financials, these are now regarded as assets. Nevertheless, members remain in control of how their portion of such funds could be used to cover their healthcare claims — well, in theory at least.

CompCare Medical Scheme chief executive and principal officer Josua Joubert, says that in practice, however, members of most medical schemes will find that some of their most common healthcare needs are frequently paid from the savings portion of their benefit structure, rather than from their scheme’s risk pool.

“While allocated benefits are replenished each year and form part of the cumulative risk pool of the scheme, members’ PMSAs can accumulate for use in the following year or be saved indefinitely for ‘a rainy day’. When schemes opt to pay more benefits out of member savings instead of the common risk pool, member savings are quickly depleted – thereby largely frustrating members’ saving efforts,” he explains.

“This approach signifies that such schemes regard members’ savings as scheme assets in a broader sense rather than simply a shift in how these funds are reported on from one side of the balance sheet to the other. In such schemes therefore, savings become little more than a mirage, often evaporating entirely before a member reaches a stage where they may really need access to such funds.”

While brokers are familiar with this increasingly ubiquitous claims payment structure, many members – particularly those who are new to private healthcare cover and may not read all the fine print – take for granted that many of these types of claims will be paid from risk rather than savings.

“At CompCare, however, we look for ways to preserve member savings through funding important wellness and preventative benefits, as well as oncology and speciality care, from our pooled scheme resources rather than tapping into members’ PMSAs,” adds Joubert.

He notes that CompCare was one of the first schemes to fund the HPV vaccine for the prevention of cervical cancer from risk rather than member savings.

“Our philosophy is to support and enhance members’ wellness so they can live healthier, active lives. Penalising members for taking responsible care of themselves by taking funds from their savings accounts simply does not make sense, which is why all our benefit options – including our entry-level hospital plan – pay more benefits from our risk pool instead, yielding substantially more value for our members.”

CompCare members are therefore in a position to enjoy more accumulated savings, and choice over how their PMSA funds are utilised, enabling them to save for those healthcare extras they may one day need. Few other open medical schemes can vouch for protecting member savings while at the same time sustaining healthy financial reserves.

“The health of our members is their greatest asset, and we consider our members to be our greatest asset. Financial reporting aside, we still very much regard members’ savings as their asset, rather than the scheme’s, and which should be protected and preserved as far as possible,” Joubert concludes.

Quick Polls


Can we really afford to ring-fence this cash for retirement when we have real 'life and death' money issues in the present? Should retirement fund assets be more accessible to members?


fanews magazine
FAnews June 2020 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

The crisis is not over
Ethics of lockdown - What value is attached to a human life?
Pandemic redefines the commercial and legal risk landscape
New partnerships needed to create an epidemic and pandemic risk programme
Credible statistics create much needed certainty
SA fixed income: Searching for value in a sea of pandemic risk
Subscribe now