orangeblock

A real shocker as gross domestic product tumbles

29 May 2008 | Economy | General | Gareth Stokes

Earlier this year a certain government minister told the country that Eskom’s pathetic January power delivery would not impact on the country’s growth. Even finance minister Trevor Manuel supported this story, steadfastly sticking to government’s 4% growth target. But economic analysts were closer to the mark. Polled a couple of weeks before Statistics SA’s Tuesday release they predicted Q1 2008 GPD growth at 2.5%.

The final number couldn’t even live up to these ‘tempered’ expectations. When all the fanfare was over we were left wondering what growth of 2.1% meant for South Africa’s hopes and dreams! Incidentally this is the worst quarter on record since Q3 2001!

Government needs 6% to meet its ambitious targets

The first observation we’d like to make is that government needs consistent GDP growth of 6% or better to have any hope of meeting its 2014 social targets. There is no other way the country will halve unemployment and poverty over the next eight years. And although economists maintain that government’s 2014 targets are nothing but a pipe-dream it seems unlikely the targets will be softened. What will happen when the targets are missed?

We’ve already seen alarming economic undertones in the recent wave of xenophobic attacks in and around the country’s informal settlements. And although the country’s porous border has exacerbated the problem there is little doubt that the gap between the ‘rich and ‘poor’ has fuelled the fire. If poverty and unemployment are not addressed we could see this type of violence escalate… And the country can ill afford such outbreaks.

Construction gets the gold star

A closer look at the latest GDP data reveals some interesting developments. Let’s begin with a look at the poorest performing segments of the economy. There’s no question that mining (down 22.1%), electricity, gas & water (down 6.2%) and manufacturing (down 1%) dragged the overall economy down. And we’re 100% certain the major reason for these declines was the forced electricity ‘rationing’ that dominated the first month of 2008. Without constant electricity supply mining and manufacturing simply cannot perform... Luckily mining carries a lower weight in the overall GDP calculation than it did a decade ago. Its current 5.4% weighting prevented the GDP number from falling even further.

The shining performances in the latest numbers came from construction (up 14.9%) and agriculture (up 12.5%). We all know why construction is performing so well. There is an abundance of massive infrastructure projects underway at the moment which will keep the country’s construction giants busy for years to come. We have stadiums for the Soccer World Cup, Gautrain and a number of huge social development projects underway. Agriculture presents a bit of a modern-day ‘catch 22’ because local consumers are likely to pay higher food prices despite the agricultures sector being in good health. Farmers will be able to achieve ‘international’ prices for their crops due to global shortages.

The middle of the road performances came from finance & real estate (up 4.9%), government services (4.5% higher), personal services (up 3.9%) and transport & communications (up 3.5%). These numbers support a general robustness in the economy and prompted some economists to say that Mboweni now has the motivation he needs to push interest rates higher, because GDP has been pulled down by power supply problems rather than a severe contraction in consumer backed sectors.

It might be time to build that ‘bomb’ shelter

And their observations couldn’t have been more correct. Yesterday, online financial news provider Fin24 carried a frightening article on the Reserve Bank’s next step. We’re not sure if they were trying to scare the public; but they suggest that governor Tito Mboweni and his MPC cohorts might hike interest rate by 200 basis points when they meet in June. That would take the prime lending rate from 15% to 17% and certainly prove a death blow to many consumers.

FAnews Online will be surprised if the governor takes such a decisive step. It’s more likely that he’s preparing us for a 1% increase... If he can scare us enough now with the threat of a 2% hike we’ll be relieved (rather than outraged) with the 1% he has planned.

Editor’s thoughts:
Although the domestic economy is powering ahead on the back of construction and higher resources prices consumers are having a tough time of it. We don’t seem able to escape the ravages of inflation as food, petrol prices and surging interest rates decimate our disposable income. Will you survive if interest rates go 2% higher in June this year? Add your comments below, or send them to [email protected]

Comments

Added by Q, 04 Jun 2008
I would like to give some feedback regarding this “scare tactic” if we can call it that... I am a recent CFP graduate and have been dealing with many clients in terms of debt consolidation by utilising untapped equity in their property portfolios, this has been successful in many ways due to the fact that some clients are getting mortgage lending rates from the major banks at prime or prime plus... We have been able to offer better rates as bond originators and have been planning portfolios to assist clients in the already tight squeeze that we feel ourselves in (I say this because I myself am included in this group!). In essence we have freed up cash in clients portfolios, consolidated debt, paid off high interest debt, and have thus allowed the client to be able to maintain the type of lifestyle that they had grown accustomed to over the last five to ten years, this now adds a lot more pressure on the middle income earning market – who are the driving force within the economy – in which downsizing and selling off assets at a loss may occur and this could see many more South Africans falling deeper and deeper into debt. It almost feels as if a strategic plot has been set into motion in which current hard working, tax-paying, legally land owning South Africans are soon to be displaced from their homes because they can’t afford to pay their monthly bond repayments and car repayments, besides the increasing cost to actually get into work each day, petrol prices soaring, traffic not even easing due to this and yet no one has thought of subsidising mortgage lending rates perhaps on its own but allow increases in other sectors. At least in this way everyday South Africans will find a way to make sure that they keep a hold onto their “homes”*... *{other fixed assets}, we can handle the petrol price going up, we still pay relatively much cheaper prices if you convert into Rands what you would pay in London or Sydney or New York for instance. Food we also understand, everyone needs to make maximum profit now because the farmer also has to pay for his land (which he might lose in the near future...), so by increasing the interest rates by 200 basis points without even considering a concession to the bond payer and investor really is looking bleak. I’m wondering if I should pack up with my wife and 9 week old baby daughter and go elsewhere? But where, Africa is in our blood, I am truly proud to be South African, yet each day my heart sinks deeper and deeper in despair, don’t get me wrong, I am an eternal optimist, it’s just now there’s a lot more to consider, bringing up a daughter in a country with one of the highest rape statistics, not to mention infant and child molestation, violence, anger, hatred and rage... Xenophobia may have a long arm and I am not going to be considered “South African” because I am of Asian descent – the previously and currently disadvantaged Asian minority. My family went through hell during apartheid and had their homes removed from them, their assets taken away – my father Chinese and mother Afrikaans – they were penalised with the immorality act, amongst other apartheid laws and regulations that they had broken (living together, etc.). So where does that leave us? We are going to be displaced from our homes, attacked because we don’t “look” or “smell” South African? Is there a light at the end of this dark tunnel, should we just put on blinders and ignore what is going on and just hope that somehow everything will be ok, that our leaders and governors are doing a good enough job – will South Africa go the same way Zim has, what is there that we can do, is there anything we can do? The eternal optimist whose optimism has been tainted,
Report Abuse
Added by CV, 04 Jun 2008
Dear Gareth, What is the matter with everyone? The problems are obvious. 1. A dysfunctional government.. Instead of job creation they are so busy with their own little agendas (and laws) which destroys initiatives and existing jobs. Just take all the FSB rules which will cause job losses of 60 000 to 70 000 in the first year if implemented (as and when commission). Marketer will not sell anything which will take 4-7 years to recoup their input costs. If they don't, guess what will happen to the staff who used to process and monitor these products? These obvious blunders will take me the next week to expose. Think Escom, foreign influx, bribery, not effective legal system, focusing on crap rather than real issues, a president who is more offshore (71%) than attending to local problems; function upon function at taxpayers expense. I feel sick just starting to think about it. 2. The oil price. Just taking what the oil price was the beginning of 2007 vs. now would suggest a 100% increase in petrol, etc. which affects every sector of every industry which has a domino effect on everything else. Food has to increase because it takes petrol to produce and to deliver, etc. Obvious. It is imported inflation..... Don't kill the piano player. Interest should be lowered by 6-7% to counter act this artificial cost as most businesses work on overdrafts. You are in actual fact adding artificial cost onto products (inflation) when you are increasing the interest rates 3. The National Credit Act has already stopped (and capped) credit which is a prerequisite to curb inflation. Buying power in the next 12 months as a result of this will be less than 5 yrs ago. Duh........ How obvious is this?. Gareth, if they drop the repo rate tomorrow by 7% you'll see a turnabout in the economy that will shock everyone. Then instruct the government to cut all their social and non essential function down by 70% and we'll be able to build another 50 000 homes. Don't give the contracts to BEE companies as they will all have to be rebuild as most other BEE contracts.. We'll have to become proud South African orientated, not colour, then we will prosper and be successful. Think with our brains, not our emotions. Use common sense and think on our feet, not intellectual and think from a book. WOW, I feel better now
Report Abuse
Added by Sarel, 02 Jun 2008
I am not intimitely familiar with all the relevant economic indicators, but a (maybe) subjective view I personally hold, is that much of the inflationary contributors are external - oil prices (for our petrol) and international food prices (obviously impacting OUR food prices). Add the ever increasing salary demands - sometimes above inflaion, the above inflation municipal increases, AND the increasing interest rates themselves, we are in a cath-22, from which I don't see a quick escape, and which (in my mind) will NOT be solved by further hiking the interest rate. Interest rates will supress the demand of goods purchased on credit (cars, furniture, white-goods, Audio-visual etc.). I believe that the people that couldn't afford it 6 months ago, will not buy it now. People who could afford it 6 months ago, probably still can. . . . Hiking the interest rates will only hurt the ones who couldn't afford it 6 months ago already.
Report Abuse
Added by JOSHUA MATHEBULA, 30 May 2008
2% interest rate hike will cause country wide strikes and the economy will be worse affected as unions will demand more money which is above inflation rate.
Report Abuse
Added by lucas, 29 May 2008
Dit is verregaande!!!!!!!! Wil hulle nou die hele land in armmoede dompel. Hulle moet nie die rentekoerse die heeltyd opsit nie. Wag eerder 'n ruk sodat die vorige verhoging 'n effek kan toon. Ons is weer oppad na '98 se 24% toe.
Report Abuse
Added by Amanda Van Rooyen, 29 May 2008
Ek sal baie moeilik nog so n groot verhoging in rentekoerse kan oorleef. n Mens kan ook net soveel op ander plekke afknyp !Waar gaan dit eindig!!!
Report Abuse
Added by bekommerd, 29 May 2008
ek dink mboweni se oordeel is nie meer logies nie.die situasie het lankal reeds hand uitgeruk en nou wil hulle dit probeer remedie deur die rentekoers op te stoot. brandstof pryse,hoe rentekoerse en hoe voedselpryse maak dit onmoontlik vir mense om nou geld uit te gee op luukshede en snert.ek weet nie waar kom hy daaraan dat mense te spandabelrig is nie.wys my sulke mense.die superrykes miskien ja,maar hulle is nie eers 10% van die mark nie.eskom wil hulle tariewe ook verspot verhoog,wat nog minder geld in die man op straat se sak sit. ek dink dit is tyd dat hy besef dat ons eerder ons plaaslike boere moet ondersteun met subsidies en ophou kos invoer ten duurste. kospryse sal dan afkom. bestee eerder geld om ons eie brandstoflewering te ontwikkel as om ten duurste in te voer wat net alles se pryse nog opjaag. spandeer geld om alternatiewe te ontwikkel tot elektrisiteit, wat die tekort sal afbring en produksie sal styg. jaag die spul onwettige imigrante wat nog verder druk plaas op ons eie ekonomie terug na hul eie lande,wat sal keer dat ons misdaad syfer verder die hoogte inskiet en buitelandse beleggers die skrik op die lyf jaag. Maar nou ja,toe ek wakker word toe is my koffie koud. mboweni en die res van die regering weet hulle het die gravytrain nou voos gery,sy wiele kom nou af en hulle weet nie hoe om dit weer reg te maak sonder dat hulle moet erken dat hulle haat,neid en wraak teen die
Report Abuse
Added by Johan, 29 May 2008
Bekommerd-Ek verstaan nie regtig die probleem met ander regerings wat hulle boere subsidies betaal nie. Beteken dit nie dat die markprys van die voedsel dan laer is omdat die regerings deel van die prys betaal en dat die ander regerings dan in effek die gebruikers van die voedsel bevoordeel nie? Deel van die hoerhoer voedsel pryse graan pryse is dat Amerika nie meer hulle oorskot uitvoer nie maar eerder brandstof daarvan maak wat tot 'n skaarste van graan lei en gevolglik hoer pryse tot gevolg het.
Report Abuse

Comment on this Post

Name*

Email Address*

Comment*

A real shocker as gross domestic product tumbles
quick poll
Question

If you had to hazard a guess, when do you reckon the COFI Bill will be signed into law?

Answer