Show me the money?

01 June 2006 Angelo Coppola

We spoke to Francois Marais at Sanlam, had some thoughts on the questions posed by the PFA, in his recent ruling concerning smoothed bonus products.

The questions should be read in the context of the latest PFA ruling:

1. Where do all the profits go?

A :It is incorrect to call it "profit". The accumulated stabilisation reserve always belongs to the pool of policyholders in the smoothed bonus portfolio and has nothing to do with the profit of the insurer.

2. What happens to the accumulation of the funds (now swelling the stabilisation reserves in the insurers books) where there
is no market adversity for many successive years?

A: It gets declared as increased bonus rates. The maturity values of smoothed bonus policies compare well to the values of market related policies over time. When the market falls the value of market related policies drop and, smoothed bonus policies may have higher maturity values than market related policies.

When the market increases, the value of market related policies will increase immediately, while the smoothed bonus policies will increase smoothly with the annual increase in bonus rates. Competitive market forces ensure that companies declare the highest bonus rates that they can afford with financial soundness.

3. Does it remain in the insurers stabilisation reserve until years of negative returns come along, and is it then used to
top-up the policy values of remaining policyholders?

A: Yes, that is the purpose of maintaining a stabilisation reserve when markets are high (as opposed to declaring all the investment growth as bonuses)

4. Is it shared between remaining policyholders, on the one hand, and the insurers shareholders at the end of the insurers
financial year, on the other?

A: No, it only belongs to the policyholders. The shareholders must, however, stand in for the loss if the market crashes to such an extent that the market value of the fund is less than the book value based on all vested bonuses (i.e. excluding any unvested bonuses)

5. Or is it treated as a profit and declared as a dividend for the benefit of the insurers shareholders?

A: We reserve the right to edit his comment here, and we took up that right.

Editors thoughts:
* As usual Francois deals with the questions directly.
* One wonders whether the PFAs understanding is indicative of a larger issue, and that is the fact that these and other
financial services products have been over-engineered and have thus become too complicated, and perhaps too expensive?

Quick Polls


Each year ordinary consumers and their financial and wealth advisers flock to dozens of asset manager ‘outlook’ presentations to find out about economic and investment trends, and the next ‘hot’ company. What do you want asset managers to share during these events?


Asset allocation strategies
Big picture investment themes and how to position portfolios for them
Investment methodologies and historic fund yields
Share tips by the score
fanews magazine
FAnews June 2022 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

A free smoothie does not make a loyal customer
Consequential loss policy court cases
Everything you need to know about death, disability and severe illness cover post-emigration
Are advisers doing all they can for clients’ portfolios?
Financial advisers need help - navigating the complex ESG fund environment
Subscribe now