COFI Act: A progressive approach to regulating an industry

24 June 2019 Johan Ferreira, Chief Legal and Compliance Officer at African Unity
Johan Ferreira, Chief Legal and Compliance Officer at African Unity

Johan Ferreira, Chief Legal and Compliance Officer at African Unity

The 2008 global financial crisis, which caused financial ruin for many individuals and companies and threw several economies into recession, brought to light the consequences of a weak and poorly regulated financial sector and provided impetus for South Africa to take stock of its own financial sector regulation.

While South African financial institutions came though the crisis relatively unscathed, evidence of poor market conduct, the peddling of inappropriate financial products to the poor and vulnerable; and, outdated legislation unable to keep pace with the fast evolving industry were amongst the factors that led to a reform of the financial sector.

The Twin Peaks reform, brought into operation the Prudential Authority for prudential regulation and the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) for market conduct regulation.

A cornerstone of this reform is the need for stronger market conduct regulation, resulting in better customer outcomes and fair treatment of customers. While the FSR Act focusses primarily on the regulators, the Conduct of Financial Institutions Act (COFI) will have its focus on the institutions.

Chief Legal and Compliance Officer at African Unity, Johan Ferreira explains that the COFI Act is also supportive of financial inclusion for all South Africans, a principle that is backed up by National Treasury’s explanatory paper accompanying the COFI Bill.

This paper stresses the role that an efficient financial sector can play in creating greater economic inclusion, especially of historically marginalized people, by fostering growth and creating employment.

The document further states that: ‘Strong market conduct policy is a critical pillar in building a financial sector that delivers these outcomes. It can support and facilitate better competition and participation in the financial sector, including of emerging black-owned financial institutions.’

Ferreira says that the COFI Bill streamlines all of the current market conduct legislation into one and, unlike most other legislation, is outcomes-based.

“COFI is based on a set of key principles which will focus on achievements within the spirit of the law rather than a tick-box approach to compliance with the letter of the law”, he says.

These principles include that the legislation is:

• Activity based: The Bill provides for regulation and supervision of activities undertaken, regardless of the institution performing the activity, thereby closing the gaps that exist in the current legal framework.

• Principles based: The Bill specifies standards related to the intention of the regulation rather than rules for compliance of the regulation. This will enable the regulator to monitor and enforce the outcomes achieved, i.e. focus on the spirit of the law, rather than the letter of the law.

• Outcomes-focused: The Bill supports the delivery of required policy outcomes and provides for monitoring of the extent to which the outcomes are being achieved and interventions for poor outcomes. This approach requires that, the market conduct of licensed financial institutions; the financial sector regulatory framework; and, the effectiveness of the market conduct regulator is tested against the desired financial sector outcomes.

• Risk-based and proportionate: The Bill provides for a risk-based approach to monitoring outcomes. The legislation will enable the regulator to identify areas of greater risk and to address these risks in a proportional manner. This will allow a fairer environment for institutions of differing sizes and will encourage new entrants into the market by reducing barriers to entry.

Ferreira believes that this risk-based approach will support competition, making it easier for new entrants into the market through provisions for different licensing to be applied to different types of companies.

He adds that this will afford the regulator greater flexibility and better tools to encourage emerging institutions and black-owned businesses to enter the market. “This will foster transformation because it allows new entrants more compliance leeway providing an environment for the company to develop and grow”, said Ferreira.

Transformation of the sector is also taken into account in the Act, which will require that all financial institutions have policies in place to comply with the B-BBEEE Code. Ferreira explains that the FSCA will have the responsibility of supervising the implementation of these policies.

While there have been critics of the introduction of the Twin Peaks reform, Ferreira believes that this has mostly been around the costs of implementing new legislation.

“Initially, financial institutions may have to increase their compliance budgets and upgrade their systems to accommodate these new requirements, but over time they will become entrenched into the business”, he said.

Ferreira believes, however, that COFI is a progressive piece of legislation that will be good for both customers and financial institutions.

“For customers, it will mean that they can be confident that they’re being properly informed and treated fairly. For financial institutions, it will mean a certain amount of flexibility in achieving the required outcomes”, he concluded.

Quick Polls


No developing economy has ever built a single-payer complementary NHI equivalent covering the entire population. NHI promises comprehensive care but it is also 100% free at the point-of-service. Is this practical?


It is doable but collaboration is key
South Africa is not in a position to build NHI
The only conclusion possible is that the private healthcare sector is not going to disappear or change
There is little chance that the NHI will be able to receive significant government funding
A E fanews magazine
FAnews August 2019 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Create designer policies through AI
Are advisers in a precarious position?
A claim, COIDA and a dog bite
Non-disclosure never an innocent fraud
Prescribed assets: The threat to pensions
Cannabis and the issue of trust
Getting the most from disability claims
Subscribe now