Can you afford to self-insure?

10 August 2016 Raimund Snyders, Mutual & Federal
Raimund Snyders, Chief Executive of Mutual & Federal.

Raimund Snyders, Chief Executive of Mutual & Federal.

Being uninsured is actually the most expensive insurance you can get.

All people with possessions are insured. However, some choose to self-insure and thus they carry the full premium risk. So it is relevant to ask: ‘How do you choose to insure and what option can you actually afford in the event of a crisis?’

This is according to Raimund Snyders, Chief Executive of Mutual & Federal, who says: “When you take out insurance, you are pooling your risk and your individual premiums are generally lower than the cost of a possible repair or replacement. But what about those who don’t insure their possessions? Traditionally we have referred to this as being uninsured, but another way of looking at it is to say that they are self-insured.”

“In South Africa we estimate that 60% of the population that should have short-term insurance does not actually take out this kind of insurance, whether it is on their vehicle or their household possessions. So they will, of course, be able to save on monthly premiums, but if the worst happens and, for example, they suffer severe damage to their vehicle, or worse still a complete loss, they will have to self-fund the full costs of repairing or replacing the vehicle. In this case, we can say that the premium then equals the loss, and so the total risk suffered will likely be more than the premiums paid, had they insured their vehicles”

In some communities, people informally pool their risks, where they then club together to help each other where a loss is suffered. This is also a form of insurance, though less structured.

Snyders says it is important for individuals to look at how they choose to insure, whether by self-insuring or by being part of a pool within the community. “If you take out insurance you are pooling your risk in a managed way and the premiums you pay should be lower than the cost of repair is likely to be. Those who choose to self-insure should ask themselves: ‘Can I afford to lose my car?’ and ‘Can I afford to self-insure?’ because self-insurance is the most expensive insurance you can get.”

He adds that from an insurance perspective, living in South Africa poses high risks in certain areas such as accidents and crime. “Our economic and social environment brings a high risk environment in these respects. People only have to access the news to see how often South Africans suffer loss. For me, this begs the questions: are you wise to self-insure? Are you making a bet that you can afford, or are you not better off actually pooling that risk, protecting your assists by making a monthly instalment into a combined insurance fund? I would suggest that it is inherently better to try to share the risk of a loss occurring with other people than it is to self-insure.”

Snyders says that South Africa compares quite well to other developed markets that have progressed to a degree in terms of their overall levels of insurance. “On an aggregate basis we compare well, for example we see 2.7% GDP percentage paid in terms of short-term insurance premiums).”

While business conditions remain tough within the economy overall, and are likely to remain so for some time, Snyders says there is scope to improve Mutual & Federal’s market penetration in the uninsured space through offering its insurance solutions to the wider Old Mutual Group.

“By and large, consumers in the black middle and lower middle income bands form a significant part of the self-insured segment of the population. They are economically active but choose to self-insure, and so therein lies a good option for us.”

Snyders says Mutual & Federal has an unparalleled footprint of Old Mutual advisers in the market who are serving their clients by catering to their overall financial needs, and that by tapping into that footprint, Mutual & Federal can prioritise insurance to existing customers of the Old Mutual Group.

He concludes, “We have a major competitive advantage in being part of the Old Mutual Group, and we have already started to see an improvement in the number of customers on our books, representing solid and profitable businesses. In this respect, tapping into the important uninsured market through our existing Old Mutual client’s dovetails very well, as the Old Mutual customer base is well spread over the emerging black middle-income clients as well as including affluent customers. We are set on our journey to be our customers’ most trusted general insurance provider across Africa and help them to turn setbacks into comebacks”

Quick Polls


The shocking crime and motor vehicle accident statistics shared during a recent SHA presentation suggests that group personal accident and personal accident cover are a no-brainer. Do you agree?


Not sure
fanews magazine
FAnews April 2024 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

FAIS Ombud lashes broker for multiple compliance blunders
TCF… a regulatory misfit initiative?
The impact of NHI on medical malpractice insurance
Fixed versus variable: can you have your cake and eat it too?
The future world of work
Subscribe now