FANews
FANews
RELATED CATEGORIES

Vexatious legal review by 4AX no disruption to ZAR X business as usual

27 June 2017 Geoff Cook, ZAR X
Geoff Cook, director and cofounder of ZAR X.

Geoff Cook, director and cofounder of ZAR X.

High court legal process likely to take years.

The review application filed in the high court by 4AX this week is the third time that 4AX has tried to exploit legal process to stifle ZAR X as a competitor. In their last attempt in January of this year, the Financial Services Board (FSB) Appeal Board, chaired by retired Judge LTC Harms, delivered a comprehensive judgement dismissing with costs the allegations that 4AX now seek to have reconsidered by yet another court.

4AX appears unable to fully comprehend the innovation inherent in the ZAR X exchange model, whose rules and procedures are based substantively on the new Australian and European Union requirements.

The proven legitimacy of these internationally recognised requirements was a significant reason for companies of the stature of Capitalworx, Futuregrowth, and Brimstone choosing to invest in establishing ZAR X as a world class exchange.

4AX, whose licence was granted on the same day as ZAR X’s despite applying for its license some 4 months after ZAR X, is following a court process that is notoriously cumbersome and lengthy.

“From our perspective, the process has mostly nuisance value,” says ZAR X director and cofounder, Geoff Cook. “We are confident that the courts will affirm the thoroughness of the ZAR X licence granting process followed by both the FSB Registrar and Appeal Board. So, we are simply continuing to focus on and grow our business. Since we started operations in February, we’ve listed Senwes, Senwes Bel, and TWK and admitted seven brokers.

“We are processing additional applications for listing within the next several weeks and assessing new broker applications. We’re also working on innovative new markets that will be announced in the last quarter of the year.

“However, from the perspective of the financial market as a whole and of the economy, this kind of vexatious litigation is a futile attempt to hinder competition and is damaging to the market as a whole. It calls into question the capabilities and bona fides of an executive team that is prepared to go to such extraordinary cost and lengths to cast negative aspersions to try and eliminate competition and innovation in the sector. At the very least, this conduct is questionable in that 4AX is expending its own investors’ funds whilst not yet operational – and this in pursuit of an outcome that is unlikely and inexcusable because it seeks to inhibit financial inclusion and access.

“The review amounts to a slur on the reputation of what is globally acknowledged as one of the world’s best regulated financial markets.

“It is both unfortunate and regrettable that issuers, investors, and brokers alike are being unwittingly dragged into a contrived situation. The fact that 4AX has yet to start operations makes their approach even more reprehensible.

“For the sake of the industry, we will defend the matter vigorously and seek a further order for costs against 4AX.”

Quick Polls

QUESTION

What is ONE of the biggest challenges you face in your career as a financial adviser?

ANSWER

Limited career growth and development opportunities
Restrictive product offerings that don’t meet all client needs
A lack of support or recognition from Financial Services Providers (FSPs)
Changing client expectations and shifting market trends
High administrative and compliance burdens that limit time with clients
Difficulty in differentiating my value in a competitive market
Increased pressure to integrate technology and digital tools into my practice
Navigating economic uncertainty and its impact on clients’ financial decisions
Balancing business growth with maintaining strong client relationships
The unpredictability of commission-based earnings
fanews magazine
FAnews February 2025 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Unseen risks: insuring against the impact of AI gone wrong
Machine vs human: finding the balance
Is embedded insurance the end of traditional broker channels?
Client aspirations take centre stage as advisers rethink retirement planning
Maximise TFSA contributions before year-end
Subscribe now