COVID-19 Scenarios: What do they mean for insurers?

28 August 2020 Claude Hamman, Head of Specialist Risk Advisory at Indwe

This is part two in a series of six blog posts providing COVID-19 risk advice. In part one we unpacked the insurance risks associated with COVID-19.

The concept of insurance is based on the premise of “the many paying for the few”, therefore insurers are not inclined to insure economic loss affecting an entire market or country simultaneously. A potential worst case scenario for the insurance markets is that insurers are required to indemnify clients without ever intending to cover loss of income as a result of a global pandemic and national lockdown. This scenario will impact solvency requirement and expose global insurers and re-insurers to these losses. Each policy will, however, have to be judged on its merits to determine the validity of the claim.

The alternative scenario or best case for insurers would have the opposite effect but would leave thousands of businesses without a lifeline and most likely result in the closure of many small businesses. The pending court cases will provide legal certainty on the way forward, in the interim, local insurance markets have committed to providing interim relief to support affected business (based on the policy wording) with the required policy extensions in place.

The global insurance markets have been exposed to multiple catastrophic losses over the past decade, resulting in a reduction in available risk capital. This has created a hardening market as insurers have become unwilling to take on risk without effective mitigation measures in place. Many South African and international insurance markets have reduced capacity and increased their rates as a result of this hardening market.

COVID-19 will likely lead insurers to carefully consider their exposures and, if the worst-case scenarios come to pass, many business are likely to see significant increases in premiums or face the possibility of being uninsured if they have too many undesirable risks.

There are insurers that would consider underwriting undesirable risks subject to specific warranties and risk control improvements being implemented by the insured. The problem arises at claims stage when large and/or complex claims are lodged with the insurer.

Firstly, has the company adhered to the warranties and completed the relevant risk management improvements as promised? Often companies are eager to agree to said warranties and risk control improvements without understanding what this will require and cost to complete.

Secondly, insurers can take inordinate amounts of time to process complex claims only to be repudiated and handed to the legal team to battle out in the courts. This tactic, in particular, should be considered ahead of selecting preferred insurance markets.

An insurance contract is one of utmost good faith between the parties and if one party knowingly enters into a contract with the intention to delay and eventually renege on their obligations, this results in many questions being asked around the value of insurance. 

Read part three in our risk advice series: What should insurance and risk management advisors be doing?

Bookmark and Share


Quick Polls


The intention with lockdown was to delay or flatten the Covid-19 infection curve and give both the private and public healthcare sectors time to prepare for the inevitable onslaught. Did the strategy work?


No, the true numbers are not reflected. Almost a quarter of South Africans may already have been infected with Covid-19
It’s too soon to tell. We will likely get a second wave with stringent lockdown regulations in place again
Yes, South Africa bought enough time to make a significant difference. We saved lives and have passed our peak. The worst is over
fanews magazine
FAnews August 2020 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Ethical behaviour - are you toeing the line?
Latest business interruption developments raise more questions than answers
Brokers remember: You are accountable...
A sustainable pension - How to manage living annuities in uncertain times
Claim stats… life can change in a heartbeat
Are South Africa’s income protection benefit providers ready for COVID-19?
Subscribe now