FANews
FANews
RELATED CATEGORIES

Theft makes South African scrap metal industry a risky business

16 October 2008 Alexander Forbes Risk Services

With steel prices still relatively high, members of South Africa’s equally buoyant crime industry have been helping themselves to every manhole cover - or any other scrap of metal not bolted down or electrified with Eskom’s priciest.

“In short, metal theft, along with the theft of the alloys used in the production of steel, is on the increase - posing both a financial and liability risk to the industry”, says Simon Baker, Business Unit Manager, Alexander Forbes Risk Services.

Apart from the likelihood that many scrap metal dealers and even steel producers knowingly receive stolen material, the risk for the industry doesn’t end there.

Fraud and theft, loss and liability threaten almost every part of the scrap metal and steel production chain in South Africa.

For example, fraud abounds. “Scrap trucks are rolled on to weigh bridges with their water tanks filled, registering a higher tonnage. Weigh bridge operators are bribed to recalibrate weigh bridges or allow the same trucks to be weighed twice”, says Baker.

Furthermore, radio active material can be illegally hidden in scrap metal. Most scrap dealers should have Geiger counters to weed out radio active scrap. In South Africa, however, many scrap dealers either don’t have these counters or assume that any scrap they receive has already been scanned.

Radio activity survives the smelting process and can end up in new steel. It will also permanently radiate the smelter and all future metal that passes through the smelter.

“You can imagine the insurance implications, in liability, lost production and plant replacement, for a smelter that became radiated through the receipt of radio active scrap”, says Baker.

Also, the production of steel involves adding various special alloys. Since these alloys are expensive and are currently increasing in price, it makes financial sense, on paper, to buy them in bulk and store them ahead of production.

Given the value of alloys, however, they pose a high theft risk.

If producers bulk storing alloys do not insure them and they are stolen before production, they will have to be replaced.

In the current market uninsured alloys will need to be repurchased at higher prices which could, says Baker, “Result in several months steel production being sold at a loss as input costs exceed selling price.”

And even if alloys are insured, producers need to make sure that they keep updating their insurance in line with alloy price increases.

Quick Polls

QUESTION

Insurers are going next level on rating property risks. How are your clients responding to the use of geotagging | geo-mapping in underwriting?

ANSWER

Premium is all they care about
They accept it, reluctantly
They are pushing back
They see the value
fanews magazine
FAnews February 2025 Get the latest issue of FAnews

This month's headlines

Unseen risks: insuring against the impact of AI gone wrong
Machine vs human: finding the balance
Is embedded insurance the end of traditional broker channels?
Client aspirations take centre stage as advisers rethink retirement planning
Maximise TFSA contributions before year-end
Subscribe now